
I am almost too weary to add a post on this issue, but thought that perhaps we all have a duty to try and put a bit of balance into the subject.
We have of course seen the press going wild because the Pope has once again reiterated the Catholic teaching against condoms (as if this is some sort of shocking surprise). So France have gone all officially self righteous claiming that the Pope's views go against the scientific consensus, Germany has thrown in her two pence worth, and apparently some Green MEP has likened the Popes views to mass murder. It is all stuff and nonsense of course. Thankfully after initially joining in on the lunacy the BBC has eventually come to produce slightly more balanced coverage of the
issue.
So here goes:
The Pope is NOT saying that using condoms makes a sexually promiscuous person more likely to catch aids than if they didn't use condoms. He is NOT saying that people should have numerous partners and not use condoms. That would indeed be lunacy, but this is almost how some have reported it.
The Pope IS saying that the only way to avoid AIDS, and see it completely wiped out, is to follow Catholic sexual teaching and either abstain from sex, or keep sex within a lifelong monogamous relationship between a man and woman. In this situation AIDS will not spread. This is simple fact.
What the pope is also saying is that encouraging condom use actually encourages the myth of "safe sex" i.e. the myth that it is OK to sleep around because it can be done "safely". The reality is that it is this very sleeping around that leads to the transmission of sexual diseases in the first place. The more sexual partners, the more the likelihood of contracting a sexually transmitted disease... EVEN with a condom. The only true protection against STD's is monogamy or abstinence!
That is what the Pope is saying, and actually it is simply common sense, the wilful misrepresentation of the Pope's views says more about those who do the reporting than it does about the Pope or Catholics, but I guess that is simply part of the package for those who dare to speak the truth.